- From: david.nickerson at nus.edu.sg (David Nickerson)
- Subject: [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML1.1.1specification
- Date: Wed, 18 Jul 2007 13:20:07 +0800
Hi Matt,
>
I think there does need to be some description of what the parts of a
>
cellml specification version number is and how it relates to the
>
cellml namespace(s).
>
>
My understanding is that the 1.1.1 was chosen so that this did
>
represent a minor step in thinking for CellML 1.1, but that the model
>
remains valid as a 1.1 model. i.e. A CellML 1.1 model is not
>
necessarily a valid 1.1.1 model and a migration step would be needed
>
to make it so. The namespace of a 1.1.1 model would still be
>
http://www.cellml.org/cellml/1.1#
>
>
I also think that this minor version should be marked in glaring red
>
that it is precisely a depreciation of reactions step and provide
>
reasons why and the tools to help people transform any models they
>
have with reactions into ones that don't. I think there will be some
>
debate around that - especially pointing to lossless transforms
>
between SBML and CellML and back again with existing transforms
>
available out there.
>
>
My assumption would be that CellML 1.2 or 2.0 namespace would be the
>
one where reaction elements become invalid if indeed 1.1.1 was
>
successful.
you seem to be saying that version 1.1.1 is marking the reaction element
for deprecation but that the reaction element itself won't become
invalid until a 1.2 or 2.0 version is released? This doesn't seem to
match with completely removing all reference of and to reaction elements
in the 1.1.1 specification...maybe I'm missing something?
Andre.
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML 1.1.1 specification, cellml-tracker at cellml.org, 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML 1.1.1 specification, Andrew Miller, 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML 1.1.1specification, David Nickerson, 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML 1.1.1specification, Andrew Miller, 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML 1.1.1specification, Matt , 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML1.1.1specification, David Nickerson, 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42] New: CellML1.1.1specification, Andrew Miller, 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42]New: CellML1.1.1specification, David Nickerson, 07/18/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [Tracker Item 42]New: CellML1.1.1specification, James Lawson, 07/19/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [TrackerItem 42]New: CellML1.1.1specification, David Nickerson, 07/19/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [TrackerItem 42]New: CellML1.1.1specification, Andrew Miller, 07/19/2007
- [cellml-discussion] [TrackerItem 42]New: CellML1.1.1specification, David Nickerson, 07/19/2007
- [cellml-discussion] CellML 1.1.1 specification, Andrew Miller, 07/19/2007
- [cellml-discussion] CellML 1.1.1 specification, David Nickerson, 07/19/2007
- [cellml-discussion] CellML 1.1.1 specification, Andrew Miller, 07/19/2007
- [cellml-discussion] CellML 1.1.1 specification, David Nickerson, 07/19/2007
Archive powered by MHonArc 2.6.18.